We need a system of effi cient maintenance
of land records which is essential for protection
of land rights of several millions of people
in the country
The
three prime entities that are involved in the
maintenance of Land information system (LIS) are
the Department of Revenue, Department of Survey,
Settlement and Land Records, and Offi ce of land
registration. In addition to this, the appropriate
municipal or village administrative unit is also
involved. This is the convention in many states
in India. The land records in India, do not provide
ultimate title to property. In other words we
need a system of effi cient maintenance of land
records which is essential for protection of land
rights of several
millions of people in the country. Land has been
one of the most sought
after possessions in developing countries such
as ours, wherein, the land holding has socio economic
significance and status. Thus there is a need
to develop an integrated LIS. A lot can be said
and discussed about various activities and issues
that are being dealt to create a LIS in different
parts of the country. There are some success stories
in Karnataka and some efforts of Governments in
the states of Andhra Pradesh, Gujarat and Madhya
Pradesh. The importance has been recognized and
limitations of the current system are understood
at various levels. . In all these success stories
there is a systematic implementation and addressing
of local issues and sentiments. As such development
of an integrated LIS cannot be viewed as just
putting all the information in digital form and
designing a front end or a typical GUI for user
interaction by availing services of few IT experts
or MNCs. In fact the Land management in our country
is purely Indian way and it has legacies of history
and no imitation or service of prime MNCs or international
bodies has relevance or use or signifi cance for
our country. The basic issues related to data
particularly the cadastral maps in terms of micro
level components, macro level components, logical
consistency and lineage need to be addressed in
detail. The technology for land management should
be professionally precise following the principles
of surveying. Ideally it should also be socially
acceptable and economically viable.
Cadastral map and
LIS
Out of
several issues an updated cadastral map, graphical
information of the parcel with exact co-ordinates
of the corners of the fi eld and extent of the
fi eld and attribute information about land use,
soil type, details of crops and ownership are
the most sought after details of any LIS. The
scale of the map, creation of ground control points,
density of parcels and topography of the area
are the key factors to be considered in relating
the cadastral map and LIS development. The identifi
cation and establishment / measurement of ground
control points is essential for the accurate creation
or maintenance of cadastral maps. There are several
case studies involving the conventional ground
surveying methods, conjunctive utilization of
conventional surveying tools and GPS, aerial photography
and satellite imagery. These are in the form of
operational applications, technique development
programs as well as research projects. One of
the essential requirements of the cadastral survey
is the satisfaction of the property owner. Hence
the re-survey methodology must provide for the
faster handling and disposal of the disputed cases,
together with the citizen satisfaction. In the
context of requirements of the products / information,
detailed assessment of the tasks / tools involved
in cadastral mapping is to be carried out. A partial
assessment is carried out in this paper which
addresses only one or two issues related to updating
of cadastral map and geo referencing. These are
related to role of high resolution data for cadastral
map updating and utilization of GPS /DGPS data
in post processing and real time processing modes.
Role of high resolution satellite
imagery
The very
high resolution data from IKONOS, CARTOSAT and
QUICKBIRD is available with resolutions of 1 meter,
2.5 meters and 0.60 meters respectively. What
are the implications of resolution for mapping
and the accuracy? A satellite image with about
2.5 meters resolution is found to have planimetric
accuracy better than 6.5 meters after precision
processing based on a systematic study and accuracy
estimation. In the same study the one meter data
is found to provide 3 meters accuracy. As such
the direct applicability or relevance of satellite
data for cadastral level mapping need to be understood
properly. Here, there are in fact three parameters
that are found to be relevant and need to be understood.
The first parameter is the resolution of the sensor
which is understood by every one as it is given
under the specifi cations of the sensors. The
second parameter is related to the ground resolved
distance which is the size of the smallest object
detected on the image. For example the LISS III
data with 23 meters resolution shows the railway
track. Does this mean that the objects of size
1 to 2 meters can be mapped using LISS III data.
It is possible only when we are interested in
identifi cation of certain long thin features
that exhibit high contrast with their background.
The third parameter is related to planimetric
accuracy. This is concerned with mapping the features
in two dimensional domain and it is found to be
a combined result of spectral and spatial discernability.
Two different sensors operating in VNIR region
each with 80 meters or 23 meters spatial resolution
but with different spectral bandwidth and channel
allocations are found to provide different accuracies.
It is found that the spectral discernability also
plays a significant role in delineating the features
and thus infl uencing the mapping accuracy. The
significance of contrast as an infl uence on spatial
resolution illustrates the interrelationships
between the various forms of resolution and emphasizes
the reality that no single element of system resolution
can be considered in isolation from others. This
is where the infl uence of mixed pixels comes
into accuracy delineation. It is interesting to
examine the relationships between the number of
mixed pixels in a given scene and the spatial
resolution of the sensor. It is found that the
percentage of mixed pixels is low for high spatial
resolution images. The shape of an object feature
is signifi cant. Aspect ratio is ratio of length
to width. For long thin features like roads, railway
tracks etc the aspect ratio is a very high non
dimensional parameter. These features are seen
on satellite images even though the resolution
is more than the size of the feature. As such
it can be concluded at this stage that a careful
evaluation of different tools and data sources
is required for taking up any step related to
enhancing the value of the existing cadastral
maps which are on 1 to 4000 or 8000 scale. We
should keep in mind the accuracies that are feasible
and level of details that are to be identifi ed
for land record maintenance. Obviously it should
be stated that the high resolution remote sensing
data available as on today from different sensors
has potential only for thematic mapping and limited
utility for cadastral mapping or updating. Let
us in all fairness do not hesitate to conclude
that high resolution satellite data is not useful
in planning, design and implementation of LIS.
The only alternative is to go for aerial photography
or ALT survey on scales between 1: 6000 to 1:
10,000. Aerial photos where ever available can
provide 1 to 4000 scale cadastral maps. The accuracy
here is about 40 cm considering 20 microns on
the aerial photo negative with 1 to 10,000 scale.
Areas requiring survey or resurvey need to go
for this as no other method can substitute these
efforts to provide the desired accuracies for
delineating land parcels The usage of the fi nal
cadastral maps using the photographic images or
the satellite images is also very limited as the
legal boundaries of holdings cannot be determined
from the photographs without extensive checking
on the ground. In all cadastral surveys there
is a need for follow-up ground surveys to check
the actual location of legal boundaries that may
not be visible on the photographs or may have
been wrongly identifi ed. One of the great disadvantages
of aerial or satellite survey is that, except
for the ground control marks that are part of
the basic control network or framework, it does
not leave permanently demarcated points on the
ground.
DGPS
– Technology
The second
aspect is related to the application of GPS in
differential mode. For areas with reasonable cadastral
map availability, the major task of maintaining
land records and creation of Land information
system can be based on DGPS surveys which can
provide scope for georeferencing of the cadastral
maps This is possible in post processing mode
or real time operation mode. The effort required
for post processing mode is more than 10 times
the effort required for real time processing mode.
It is essential to fi x the most important feature
namely the “control point” i.e., bi
or tri-junctions (point where boundaries of villages
meet) as well as other identifi able points. Presently
cadastral maps do not contain information about
the height. As such height information can also
be incorporated in DGPS stations. This will lead
to 3d cadastral mapping in due course of time.
DGPS can provide accuracies better than 50 cm
to the control points. This is adequate for cadastral
surveys. On a map of 1 to 4000 cadastral map the
smallest feature that can be mapped is of 80 cm
or say 1 meter size. So the accuracy is far more
than the minimum mappable unit on 1 to 4000 scale
which is in fact
the major satisfying feature. There is a need
to create local reference frames or grids which
can be used for GPS survey by triangulation or
grid methods. It may be noted that the fi rst
and second order points built under the CARTOSAT
utilization projects by Department of Space, Government
of India, all over the country are very useful
for the purpose of establishing control points
or control grid and traverse running. Access to
this information is limited and possibly requires
approval and clearance by Government.
Preparation of the
georeferenced digital cadastral map
This is
essential task of the entire ILIS and basic issue.
How to go about it. With out much introduction
and explanation to the problem it can be stated
based on studies in different situations, DGPS
in real time operation mode is a better option
or solution for this problem. It is not going
to provide the solution on a turn key mode. This
has only scope and need to be calibrated. This
will help us to draw a road map for digital cadastral
map creation with minimum of the resurvey task.
The cadastral record information with reference
to parcel numbers is to be identified with the
help of land records and related government offi
cers. This is a very crucial stage of the creation
of ILIS. How to geo reference the parcel
boundaries. Also these are to be put under a standard
reference system like WGS 84 system. It is the
major issue. Several techniques of updating /
resurveying are being proposed. These include
aerial triangulation, use of total station and
GPS/DGPS, satellite image processing etc. A detailed
analysis and understanding of the potential of
the technology suggest that a RTK GPS (It is a
DGPS with real time processing capabilities) based
surveying of selected points or boundary points
and calibration is “the technological tool”
for this task in the present context. The experience
with RTK was successful in retrieving the control
points and the method was accurate for planimetric
applications and is several times faster than
traditional methods. Generally there are some
conditions which to become aware of to obtain
a satisfying accuracy by using RTK. There must
be contact to a good number of satellites and
PDOP has to be low which indicates good satellite
geometry. To apply the RTK method in cadastral
surveys it is necessary that the basic point has
a high horizontal accuracy, whereas it is suffi
cient for the determination of the z-coordinate
to use a height from a topographical map (the
accuracy of the contour lines is about 1 m in
topographical maps of scale 1:25.000). A brief
account of the achievable accuracies using DGPS
is given in Table 1. It is possible to use the
GPS method RTK for cadastral surveys. The accuracy
of the parcel coordinates is proportional to the
number of ground control points used for calibration
of GPS and georeferencing. The value of the cadastral
maps in such a situation will be enhanced signifi
cantly, because every measurement on the map is
in a referred coordinate system. In conclusion
it can be stated that the Cadastral map based
LIS must follow also a standardized data format
and prepare a protocol of accuracies so that uniformity
is maintained all over the country.
IV
Murali Krishna
Professor and Head, Centre for Spatial
Information Technology, Jawaharlal
Nehru Technological University, Hyderabad iyyanki@icorg.org