Innovative use of controlled photogrammetric
models allows for faster map making
Seven
out of ten customers of surveys and mapping who
talk to the suppliers (consulting fi rms of surveying
agencies) demand their maps to be delivered `yesterday’(!)
or indeed as early as possible. These customers
are `decision-makers’ who have taken some
months (if not years) to come to the demand level!
Same is the situation in respect of the tenders
in mapping discipline. All the risks and uncertainties
are put on the door of the suppliers / contractors.
One should realize that although the surveying
and mapping process never costs more than 1 or
2 percent of total budget, the same is not true
when it comes to the time taken for the mapping
project. The fact is that many projects are delayed
just because the survey data of right quality
and proper map was not made available to the engineer
/ planner.
The above scenario, although quite common and
acceptable through usage, should make people think
about the cardinal question – Can we cut
short or minimize the time taken for the survey
process and deliver the map tomorrow if not yesterday?
Survey profession will defi nitely earn brownie
– points if the process becomes quicker.
This paper tries to answer this question. Some
innovative juxtaposition of the photogrammetric
production process has been suggested towards
this goal.
In order to reduce the time of production, we
have to examine the photogrammetric production
processes.
The sub-process or various steps in the photogrammetric
processes are further analysed towards arriving
at the solution.
Aerial Photography
– Treat this as 90% Map
The aerial
photography in India is carried out by the National
Remote Sensing Agency, (NRSA) located at Hyderabad.
The specialized aircraft and other equipment are
also stationed at Hyderabad. The cost of aerial
photography, therefore, very much depends on the
distance of the desired survey site from Hyderabad.
The security clearance of the aerial operation
is taken by the NRSA but it takes a few months.
Besides, the fl ying season commences in September
and fi nishes in March / April. Looking at this
scenario, the customers are well advised to enter
into dialogue with NRSA right at the conception
stage of the Project and not wait for the sanction
of the Project. There is no cost of discussions
leading to the stage of obtaining security clearance.
To give an idea, the cost of the aerial photography
for an area in Delhi may range from Rs 40 to Rs
50 per hectare on 1:10,000 scale. The cost
when compared to the overall cost of photogrammetric
mapping i.e. Rs 400 to Rs 500/ha, is quite low.
Consider this with respect to the major advantage
of having almost 90% of the map information. Further,
even in a fast changing ground conditions (like
in a big town), the aerial photograph can be put
to effective use even for the next 3-4 years for
planning and monitoring. When compared to the
map, the photograph is burdened with some geometric
distortions. These distortions, however, in a
practical sense are quite insignifi cant if the
terrain is fl at. The nominal scale of the aerial
photograph can also be determined with the help
of fl ying height of the aircraft at the time
of taking photography.
Ground Control – Vital
Input to Photogrammetry
When Photogrammetry
is employed as the main production technology,
there is considerable (almost 60 to 70%) reduction
of ground control work in the fi eld as compared
to purely ground based traditional techniques.
However, Photogrammetry stipulates a minimum number
of
ground points at proper location with respect
to the incidence of the aerial photography (model)
on the ground. These ground control points create
the most important input to the process of Photogrammetry.
It is presumed that the ground control points
will be provided with the help of Global Positioning
System (GPS in differential mode). These points
are further connected to the Survey of India Stations
and Bench Marks.
Aerial
Triangulation (AT) and Digital Terrain Model (DTM)
This is
an essential photogrammetric operation in which
initial ground control (as mentioned in 2.2) is
augmented by a set of procedures on a photogrammetric
machine. The result is that all the overlapping
aerial photographs (stereo-models) will have control
points at optimum places. These control points
obtained after aerial triangulation are marked
on photographs and are later required for producing
mapping details (x, y and z) in case line map
is required. A fully digitised vector map can
also be produced at this stage.
Digital Terrain Model is produced using a mesh
/ grid of elevation points. Closer the grid, the
more accurate is the DTM. The DTM provides a `well
approximated’ model of the terrain. The
digitised data in DTM form can be further utilized
to generate contours and / or Orthophoto.
Photogrammetry
Based Mapping (Plotting)
The photogrammetric
model is set on the machine very accurately with
the help of the augmented points. The digitisation
of the mapping details (topography) and the elevations
/ contouring is done automatically while the operator
is going over the details of the 3D model through
observation – system of the machine (photogrammetric
plotter).
The control points and the DTM are also used for
incorporation in the Geographic Information System
(GIS) and for generating an Orthophoto.
Orthophoto is a digitised transformation of original
photograph from which all distortions have been
removed and proves more productive than traditional
line-maps. The Orthophoto combines the richness
of aerial photo and the accurate geometry of a
map. Incidentally, the Orthophoto mapping process
is also more cost and time effective when compared
to line mapping on a photogrammetric plotter.
Photogrammetric
Output
The photogrammetric
output, as mentioned earlier, can be in the form
of a line-map with contours or as an Orthophoto
of the area. These are the standard map-forms
especially for large-scale work e.g. utility maps
of towns, highway corridor maps, water pipe network
surveys etc.
Field Verifi
cation of Photogrammetric Output
There are
many physical features, which are not photographed
or are omitted e.g. houses under trees, underground
pipe lines etc. These features are picked up by
groundvisit. The output is, in general, checked
for any omissions or wrong interpretation also.
In case the photography is not very old (more
than 3-4 years) and the changes on the ground
are not many, say 10-15%, the changes can be surveyed
on the ground at the time of verification.
Photogrammetric Production
Process and Recommendations
Aerial Photography
Aerial
photography, as discussed, should be procured
as early as possible. It is a low investment activity
yet forms an important step. All (100%) ground-based
information is available except the `geometry’
of a map in an aerial photograph. Many requirements
e.g. planning process, environmental monitoring,
ground water studies etc can be met from an aerial
picture.
Controlled Models
The next
stages of fi eld control, Aerial Triangulation
and preparation of DTM will add `geometric value’
to the aerial photography.
This is the desired stage at which the value added
data and the aerial photography can be stored
so to say. In other words, it means that the aerial
photograph along with its value added data is
ready for any mapping requirement.
This will be the Photogrammetric Digitised Data
Base (PDDB), which can be `retrieved’ to
produce a map within a very short time of a week
or two. We can forget about the delays of some
months if not years if the Data Base is already
available in an organization. PDDB will create
an effect of fast-forward in a mapping organization
like Survey of India,
National Remote Sensing Agency, State Cadastral
Organizations and similar organizations. The mapping
organization will improve the delivery by a factor
of 12 to 15 times. The common time of production
is reduced from 24 weeks to 2 weeks.
The above concept of Photogrammetric Data Base
also facilitates the user-organization to spread
its expenditure over a longer period of say 2
to 3 years. Thus, the concentrated load of costly
mapping is also easily distributed in budgetary
allocation of organizations.
The concept is so useful that any user organization
requiring detailed and accurate maps can get these
very quickly.
Achievable Accuracy
at Different Scales of Aerial Photography
The scale
of aerial photography is designed before it is
actually fl own. The possible accuracy from the
various scales of aerial photography is now discussed.
It is assumed that smallest topographic detail
on the aerial negative (or
diapositives) which is discernable on the photograph
ranges from 20 micron to 40 micron, micron being
1/1000th part of one millimetre, Example –
Assuming 40 micron on Negative. It the scale of
photograph is 1:20,000, the smallest dimension
converted in terms of ground will be:
The scale
of map is generally 4 to 5 times larger than the
scale of aerial photography. For example, 1:4000
cadastral map can be prepared from the aerial
photography on the scales of 1:15,000 or 1:20,000
scales. Utility mapping for towns, which is required
on 1:2000 scale, can be prepared from 1:10,000
or nearby scale.
Conclusion
The motivation
for this paper started from seeking a solution
of a real problem of the map users i.e. the inordinate
delay in getting mapdata. The concept of generating
the Photogrammetric – Date – Base
does solve this problem in two ways. Firstly,
by procuring the aerial photography at the earliest
and secondly by storing the value added models
(partially completing the photogrammetric process).
Once the user organizations understand the advantages
of the concept, the implementation of the model
is quite easy.
Another acceptable advantage of the concept is
that it facilitates organizations to spread the
expenditure over a longer period of time.
October 2005
Prof
P Misra Consultant,
Land
Information Technologies, New Delhi, India
misralit@hotmail.com