There are difficulties in applying GPS directly
to indoor positioning because of the weakness
of GPS signal in an indoor environment
Recently
mobile location based services (LBS) are provided
via a mobile terminal such as a personal digital
assistant (PDA), a cellular phone and so on. The
location method that searches where the mobile
terminal of a user is accurately is a key factor
for providing convenient and useful LBS. The most
well known method associated with positioning
system is GPS. The signal of GPS satellites can
be always acquired outdoors and this system provides
comparatively accurate location information. However,
there are difficulties in applying GPS directly
to indoor positioning because of the weakness
of signal. And the positioning using the mobile
communication signal between a base station and
a cellular phone does not provide adequate accuracy
due to some technical limitations of communication
systems when applied to navigation. In addition,
severe multipaths are present in an indoor environment.
So a new wireless communication technology is
required for indoor positioning to achieve a better
and appropriate accuracy. Wireless local area
network (LAN) has been installed in a number of
indoor areas such as office, terminal, campus,
and park with interests in mobile Internet. Therefore,
it is expected that a wireless LAN signal would
be easily acquired for indoor positioning. Various
positioning measurements like time of arrival
(TOA), time difference of arrival (TDOA), and
received signal strength may be employed for indoor
positioning. Employing TOA or TDOA measurements
requires a time synchronization between a transmitter
and a receiver. But, a time synchronization between
a transmitter and a receiver is very difficult
if not impossible in a wireless LAN. Therefore,
it is more appropriate to use signal strength
for indoor positioning with a wireless LAN.
One method for indoor positioning uses a location
fingerprint that can be an average value of signal
strength over several seconds at one location.
It stores signal strength of the APs as measured
at each sample point in a database beforehand.
It then compares signal strength of a mobile user
with stored signal strength in the database to
find a sample point nearest to the user. However,
this method needs a number of sample points and
requires to build the database of received signal
strength at each sample point and to update it
since any modifications of indoor structures change
the signal strength at sample point. Another method
is based on a propagation model that describes
how a radio wave loses signal strength as it travels
through an environment. The amount of loss is
dependent on the propagation environment. The
signal strength is typically modelled by using
a log distance path loss model with a path loss
exponent. The value of the path loss exponent
depends on surroundings and building type. The
range from a mobile user to an AP can be calculated
by the signal strength loss over space. The location
of mobile user is determined by triangulation
after an estimation of more than three ranges
from the user to APs. However, this method has
a limitation in that a received signal strength
changes over time because of an obstruction and
multipath. It requires huge number of sample points
and stores each sample point’s signal strength
to compute an estimated path loss exponent in
the propagation model in advance. Then the location
of the mobile user is determined by using the
propagation model with the previous estimated
path loss exponent and the received signal strength
of the user. The location accuracy is poor when
a present path loss exponent in this model is
not the same with the estimated path loss exponent
since any modifications of indoor structure or
human movements change the received signal strength
at sample points.
Additional
reference point can be installed with APs in wireless
LAN to determine a location of a mobile user regardless
of any changes in an indoor environment. Reference
points and a mobile terminal of a user is needed
to resolve a difficulty of inconsistently received
signal strength over time due to changes of an
indoor environment. The main idea of the reference
point is generic enough to be used for other wireless
network technologies as well. A reference point
is chosen appropriately in the middle of an interested
room or indoor area to receive signals with enough
strength from all APs. The least square method
estimates the path loss exponent in this propagation
model. The path loss exponent should be determined
for each AP. The signal strength of the APs as
measured at additional reference points is used
to estimate path loss exponents. And the ranges
from the user to all APs are calculated by the
signal strength of a mobile user and estimated
path loss exponents. Finally the location of the
user is determined instantly by triangulation.
Differently with conventional propagation method,
this method does not assume a path loss exponent
in a propagation model as constant because it
estimates the path loss exponent by using received
signal strength at reference points when mobile
user request his location in an indoor environment.
This indoor positioning can be implemented in
two ways. One is handset-based implementation
and the other is network-based implementation.
Handset-based positioning system consists of three
parts, which are one mobile terminal of a user,
several APs and several reference points. The
mobile terminal stores a known location of each
AP and a location of each reference point in advance.
Each reference point monitors signal strengths
received from all APs. A mobile terminal also
monitors them similarly at the same time. The
mobile terminal estimates the path loss exponent
in a propagation model with the received signal
strength of reference points. Next, it determines
the location of the user with an estimated propagation
model and received signal strength of the mobile
terminal and already known APs’ location
and reference points’ location. Network-based
positioning system consists of four parts, which
are one mobile terminal of a user, several APs,
several reference points and one additional positioning
server. Positioning server instead of the mobile
terminal stores known APs’ location and
known reference points’ location in advance.
Each reference point monitors signal strengths
received from all APs and transfer the received
signal strength to positioning server. At the
same time received signal strength of the mobile
terminal is transferred to positioning server
similarly. The positioning server estimates a
path loss exponent in a propagation model with
already known APs’ location and reference
points’ location and signal strength received
from reference points. Next, it determines the
location of the mobile user with an estimated
propagation model and signal strength received
from the mobile terminal.
A test bed for a field experiment is established
on the sixth floor of the Automation and Systems
Research Institute building in Seoul National
University. The layout of this testing area is
depicted in Fig. 1. It has dimensions of thirty
meters by seventeen meters with ten different
rooms. Three APs are installed at the locations
indicated with star marks and three reference
points are chosen in the middle of two rooms and
a hallway at x marks. The signal strength of reference
points received from all APs is collected. Three
3COM wireless LAN access points are used for APs
in IEEE 802.11b infrastructure. And four Orinoco
wireless LAN silver network interface cards are
used for three reference points and one mobile
terminal of the user. Mobile handsets for reference
points and a mobile user are assumed as laptop
computers. An HP laptop computer is used for the
user and three Samsung laptop computers are used
for three reference points. Each AP acts as a
wireless signal transmitter and the reference
point. The mobile terminal acts as the wireless
signal receiver using a laptop computer with Lucent
Technology Orinoco wireless LAN card. This wireless
LAN card can detect the signal strength received
from APs. The mobile user is assumed to go around
two large rooms and a hallway, each of which has
a reference point. An experiment has twelve test
points and eight signal strengths received from
APs are collected at each test point for two seconds.
Fig. 2 shows the location accuracy using three
reference points for indoor positioning in the
field experiment. First, the three APs’
location is represented as star marks and the
three reference points’ location as x marks
in this figure. Next, the true position of the
mobile user is represented as circle marks and
the estimated position of the user as square marks.
The mean of location error is 2.8m and the standard
deviation of location error is 1.7m from all test
points.
The meter-level accuracy for indoor positioning
is obtained from these results. This method has
the advantages that there is no need to construct
the database of the received signal strength of
a number of sample points in advance and update
it periodically. The obstruction such as wall,
human and spatial structure in the indoor environment
need not be considered for positioning as well.
In summary, the location of a mobile user can
be determined by indoor positioning method using
wireless LAN received signal strength.
November 2005
Jaywon
Chey
School of Electrical Engineering,
Seoul National University, KOREA j1chey@korea.com
Jang
Gyu Lee
School of Electrical Engineering,
Seoul National University, KOREA jgl@snu.ac.kr
Gyu-In
Jee
Department of Electronics Engineering,
Konkuk University gijee@konkuk.ac.kr