The
combination of aerial photography and LiDAR
has great potential
With the
launch of GPS in the 1980s, the task of providing
control points
for mapping purposes was greatly simplified, leading
to economy and ease of operation. The technique
of LASER mapping, which existed decades before
GPS, also received a boost due to GPS, as instantaneous
precise positioning of the exposure station during
the mobile LASER mapping operation was made possible
by GPS, thus solving a major problem in LASER
mapping. The recent GPS modernization programme,
and the introduction of GNSS, an extension of
GPS by addition of two more satellite systems,
has further enhanced the utility of satellite
positioning for mapping applications.
GPS modernization
and GNSS
GPS is
the first surveying technique to offer applications
in a very wide range of spheres, from mm-level
high-precision geodesy to the few m-level real-time
positioning, at an unprecedented speed and low
cost. Continuing research efforts to improve the
field data collection, orbit prediction, hardware
and software developments and modelling and data
processing have contributed towards making GPS
the most widely used system of this century. The
International GPS for Geodynamics Service (IGS)
has proved the suitability of GPS for high-precision
scientific tasks such as monitoring the crustal
motions, the Earth rotation, etc. With the recently
launched GPS modernization programme, to introduce
a “civilian” code on L2 frequency,
called L2C, and a third “civilian”
frequency, called L5, the precision and integrity
of GPS is likely to increase many-folds in the
near future. The integration of GPS with the Russian
System- GLONASS, and the new European system being
launched: the GALILEO, the concept of integrated
satellite-bases positioning and navigation through
GNSS will soon become a reality. The GPS - International
Navigation System (INS) integration, kinematic
GPS survey techniques, psuedolites as substitute
for GPS in the event of outages, the launching
of Wide Area Augmentation Systems (WAAS) for civil
aviation, etc. are some of the promising developments
in this field, which will make the system most
versatile and trust-worthy in the near future.
LiDAR
The Light Detection And Ranging (LiDAR) is
a relatively new technological tool, which is
very useful for terrain mapping, and hence,
widely accepted around the world. This technology
is also known as Airborne Laser Terrain Mapping
(ALTM), Airborne Swath Mapping (ASM), Airborne
Laser Mapping (ALM) or Airborne Laser Scanning
(ALS).
LiDAR is much faster than conventional photogrammetric
technology and the data is easily combined with
other type of data, through many commercial
software products, for numerous applications.
Its development goes back to 1970s and 1980s,
with the introduction of the early NASA-LiDAR
systems, and other attempts in USA and Canada
(Ackermann, 1999). The method has successfully
established itself as an important technique,
within a few years, and quickly spread into
practical applications. By the early 1980s,
second generation LiDAR systems were in use
around the world. These were expensive and had
limited capability, and were generally used
only by federal agencies in USA. With the enhanced
computer power currently available, and with
the latest positioning and orientation systems,
including GNSS, LiDAR systems have become a
commercially viable alternative for development
of Digital Elevation Models (DEMs) of earth
surface.
LiDAR can be useful for collection of elevation
data in case of dense forests, where photogrammetry
fails to reveal the accurate terrain information,
due to dense canopy cover. Not limited by the
environmental conditions restricting aerial
photography, airborne laser scanning technology
is emerging as an attractive alternative to
the traditional technology for large-scale geospatial
data capture
LiDAR
data collection
A pulsed
laser ranging system is mounted in an aircraft
equipped with a precise kinematic GPS receiver
and an Inertial Navigation System (INS). By accurately
timing the round trip travel time of the light
pulses from the aircraft to the ground (water,
foliage, buildings or other surface features),
it is possible to determine the range with a precision
of one centimeter or better. Solid-state lasers
are now available that can produce thousands of
pulses per second, each pulse having a duration
of a few nanoseconds (10- 9 seconds). Using a
rotating mirror
inside the laser transmitter, the laser pulses
can be made to sweep through an angle, tracing
out a line on the ground. By reversing the direction
of rotation at a selected angular interval, the
laser pulses can be made to scan back and forth
along a line. When such a laser ranging system
is mounted in an aircraft with the scan line perpendicular
to the direction of flight, it produces a saw
tooth pattern along the flight path as shown in
figure 2.
The width of the strip or “swath”
covered by the ranges, and the spacing between
measurement points, depends on the scan angle
of the laser ranging system and the airplane height.
Using a light twin or single engine aircraft,
typical operating parameters are: flying speeds
of 200 to 250 kilometers per hour (55 to 70 meters
per second), flying heights of 300 to 1000 meters,
scan angles generally ±30, to ±20
degrees, and pulse rates of 2000 to 50000 pulses
per second.
These parameters can be selected to yield a measurement
point every few meters, with a footprint of 10
to 15 centimeters, providing enough information
to create a Digital Terrain Model (DTM) adequate
for most applications, including the mapping of
storm damage to beaches, in a single pass. The
primary factor in the final DTM accuracy is the
airborne GPS data. Errors in the location and
orientation of the aircraft, the beam director
angle, atmospheric refraction model and several
other sources degrade the co-ordinates of the
surface point to 5 to 10 centimeters (Shrestha
and Canter, 1998).
After a flight, the precise position of the aircraft
at the exact epoch of each range measurement is
computed relative to nearby GPS ground stations
using phase differenced kinematic Global Positioning
System (DGPS) techniques. The laser ranging vectors
are added to the aircraft positions to derive
three dimensional X,Y,Z coordinates of each ground
point.
Because airborne GPS data is critical to overall
accuracy, flight layouts should optimize the GPS
component. To ensure desired accuracies, the use
of six satellites at all times during the data-collection
is preferred, although solutions can be delivered
with a minimum of four satellites. Further, ground-reference
receivers should be located every 15 kilometers
to 20 kilometers.
Comparison
with other techniques
LiDAR is
an emerging technique for data collection and
is found to be very accurate and suitable, as
compared to the currently available techniques,
like photogrammetry and RADAR. Until recently,
only conventional techniques of topographic data
collection (viz. Surveying, levelling, photogrammetry,
satellite stereogrammetry etc.) were available
to the geomatics community. These techniques suffer
from one or other limitation in terms of their
accuracy, resolution, time, site inaccessibility,
weather and sunlight dependence, etc. LiDAR, however,
promises to eliminate most of the handicaps of
conventional methods, and is establishing itself
as a major player in the topographic, data collection
industry. LiDAR is an active illumination sensor;
a laser system can collect data at night and can
be operated in the any weather and at low sun
angles, that prohibit aerial photography.
With LiDAR, DTM can be generated more rapidly
and accurately than with photogrammetry, due to
digital acquisition of the data and the direct
range measurement. Calculations show that LiDAR
requires only 25% to 33% of the budget as compared
to photogrammetric compilation (Petzold et al.,
1999).
Interferometric Synthetic Aperture Radar (InSAR)
is a new and rapidly evolving technique useful
for DEM generation, which seems to be competitor
of LiDAR in resent years. But the accuracies achieved
so far by InSAR are usually in the range of 1
meter, on the contrary, LiDAR gives vertical accuracies
in the range of 10 to 15 centimeters, which is
well tested by conducting number of pilot projects
in various countries around the world.
Layovers is a major problem in INSAR, creating
lots of problems in generating accurate DTM, especially
in the hilly terrain with wide variation in topography,
and in urban areas with skyscrapers, which introduce
significant errors. On the contrary, LiDAR is
not affected by layovers and shows promising results.
DTM generation from
LiDAR
LiDAR data
is useful for generating Digital Elevation Model
(DEM) and relief maps. DEM gives the height information
and three-dimensional view of the topography.
This information is very much useful in various
engineering and military application. The X,Y,Z
coordinates of the ground points can be processed
using a number of commercially available software
packages to produce a DEM, and many other products
such as shaded relief maps, contour maps, cross
sections and surface profiles.The ASCII data collected
by LiDAR can be imported into software like Arc-view,
Microstation, etc., to represent into point format.
After initial editing, the contours can be generated
by using software like Terramodel, GRAM++ and
Arcinfo. After interpolating contour data into
the software, Digital Surface Model (DSM) and
shaded relief map can be generated from this data
(see figure 4). The shaded relief map of the area
shown in figure 5 is generated by using GRAM++
GIS package, developed by Centre of Studies in
Resource Engineering (CSRE), IIT Bombay.
Applications
LiDAR has
numerous applications in various engineering fields;
some of which are quite unique. Some of the important
LiDAR applications are described here.
Beach Mapping
Highly
accurate, dense and rapidly obtained data sets
are most suitable for coastal applications like
sediment transport, coastal erosion and coastal
flood models. This new capability opens for the
first time the possibility to regularly monitor
the beaches, to map just prior to and immediately
after major storms, to obtain accurate quantitative
information about the extent of the damage (Shrestha
and Canter, 1998).
Forest studies
Laser-based
LiDAR systems offer distinct advantages over existing
survey instruments in areas such as forest surveys.
A unique advantage of these instruments is that
they are capable of penetrating vegetation, allowing
the ground beneath a tree canopy to be mapped
directly from the air.
Infrastructure
construction, maintenance, and management
LiDAR can
also be effectively employed for corridor mapping
to plan oil and gas pipelines, and for their post
-commission maintenance. The tasks from the field
survey to the final data delivery can be accomplished
within weeks, which otherwise, using the conventional
methods, would take months. LiDAR is useful in
generating DTM for road planning and design (Janssen
and Gomes, 1999).
Transmission
Lines Mapping
Long stretches
of transmission lines can be mapped with great
speed, to determine the exact location of the
transmission towers, accurate topography of the
corridor, and the encroachment by vegetation for
modification and repair purposes (Lohani, 2000).
Architecture
and landscape design/ Three- dimensional modeling
Automatic
integration of an architectural design with its
surrounding, represented by a highresolution 3D
landscape model obtained by LiDAR, that includes
existing vegetation, facilitates the design process
and gives an accurate impression of how your design
interacts with its surrounding.
Disaster prevention
and response
LiDAR is
very helpful to determine areas prone to natural
hazards like floods, and to rapidly assess the
damage to infrastructure after natural disasters
like earthquakes, storms, and landslides on a
larger scale.
Other applications
of LiDAR
• Landslide Mapping
• Volcano monitoring • Bathymetry
• Urban planning and development •
Ecology and environment
Integration of photogrammetry
and LiDAR
The combination
of aerial photography and LiDAR has great potential.
Results and performance could certainly be enhanced,
if laser scanning system is supplemented by taking
aerial photographs. One can imagine the benefits
of high-resolution imagery and a dense LiDAR-generated
DEM. The LiDAR DEM tends to be much denser that
those available through current sources. This
potentially leads to more accurate orthorectification.
The user enjoys the benefits of high spatial resolution
from the imagery and a very accurate, dense DEM
from the LiDAR system. For more details, see (Satale,
2003).
International and
Indian scenario
LiDAR is
commercially operational in various countries
like USA, Canada and in Europe. A few LiDAR projects
have been taken up in India recently, mostly on
pilot basis. In India, there are many of ongoing
and proposed projects related to roadways, railways,
oil and gas pipelines, electric transmission lines,
communication network, ports and harbors, for
which speedy collection of accurate topographic
data is an important factor, which reduces the
cost of the entire project dramatically. Delays
in project work due to the limitations of conventional
data collection approaches may also be minimized,
by using technologies like LiDAR. India is prone
to natural disasters of varied forms, resulting
in heavy losses of life and wealth. LiDAR data
have the potential to be effective in many disaster
management programs, including the frequently
occurring floods, like the Mumbai floods of July,
2005. The LiDAR technology can be very effectively
used for such important applications.
Conclusions
The main
advantages of LiDAR are accuracy of measurements,
high automation and fast delivery times. Due to
its typical characteristics, both in data collection
and data type, LiDAR has opened up several new
applications, which were not economically feasible
with the conventional techniques. In India the
technology is yet to make its impact on the mapping,
and has still a long way to go. Looking at the
potentials of this technology, it is obvious that
LiDAR will play a major role in geospatial applications
in near future.
Acknowledgements
The research
work related to comparison of photogrammetry and
LiDAR was carried out by the second author, under
the guidance of the first author, as part of M.Tech.
thesis.
References
[1] Ackermann, F., Airborne laser scanning
present status and future expectations. ISPRS
Journal of Photogrammetry & Remote Sensing,
Vol. 54, pp. 148,1999.
[2] Janssen, L.L.F., Gomes, L.M., Suitability
of laser data for DTM generation: a case study
in the context of road planning and design,
International Journal of Remote Sensing, Vol.54,
pp. 244, 1999.
[5] Petzold, B., Reiss, P., Stolssel, W., Laser
scanning- surveying and mapping agencies are
using a new technique for the derivation of
digital terrain models, ISPRS Journal of Photogrammetry
Engineering and Remote Sensing, Vol. 54, pp.
95, 1999.
[6] Satale, Dhananjay M., LiDAR in Mapping,
M.Tech. Dissertation, Department of Civil Engineering,
I.I.T. Bombay, 2003
[7] Shrestha, R., Carter W. E., Engineering
applications of airborne scanning lasers:Reports
from the field. Journal of Photogrammetry Engineering
and Remote Sensing,Vol. 66, pp.256, 1998.
Madhav
N Kulkarni Department Of Civil Engineering,
Indian
Institute of Technology, Bombay
kulkarni@iitb.ac.in