A
dedicated mission to observe the ionospheric
precursors of earthquakes
Early
warning of earthquakes has actually become the
main goal of seismology. And though seismic prediction
started as a purely seismological discipline,
it now involves hydrology, hydro -geochemistry,
measurement of telluric and magnetic fields etc.
The parameters under observations for the purpose
of diagnosing seismic regimes include hydro -chemical
parameters, atmospheric electrical disturbances,
electromagnetic emissions, anomalous disturbances
in the ionosphere and the magnetosphere recorded
by satellite.
Among different precursory phenomena mentioned
in the different publications on the predictions
the ionospheric predictions are probably the youngest
due to its unique ability to indicate the approximate
position of the earthquake epicenter using ground
and space-based observations. The study of seismicity
and underlying processes could be essentially
improved by using the satellite methods, as it
happened with climate and weather study, when
proper satellite information are made available.
Local probes installed onboard artificial satellites
are able to register the variations of near-earth
plasma parameters associated with the preparing
earthquakes. Probably, the first report on the
satellite measurements of ionospheric precursors
of the earthquakes could be attributed to the
beginning of 1980s. Conditionally, the precursors
observed by satellites can be divided into following
groups
i) Electromagnetic fields and noises;
ii) Plasma parameters variations;
iii) Particle fluxes.
Electromagnetic emissions in the low frequency
ranges that are related toseismic activities are
known since long time, but their generation mechanisms
are not well understood. Two types of emissions
can be considered; first, precursor emissions
occur a few hours before earthquakes in a large
frequency range from one-hundredth hertz up to
several mega hertz; secondly emissions observed
after the shock generally are attributed to the
propagation of acoustic-gravity waves (Pokhotelov
et al., 1995 and Parrot et al., 2002) However,
all hypothesis concerning the generation mechanism
of precursor emission are also valid after the
shock, when Earth’s crust returns to the
equilibrium state. The emissions can propagate
up to the ionosphere; and observations made with
low – altitude satellites have shown variations
of low frequency waves above seismic regions.
The above mentioned points can be well understood
through the block diagram given in Figure (1)
which gives the seismo-ionospheric coupling and
thereby atmospheric and ionospheric effects at
different channels. Substantial progress has been
made in developing the methods for earthquakes
hazards analysis on a timescale in
last few decades and it has been realized that
satellites and ground based facilities may detect
earthquake precursors in the ionosphere a few
hours or days before the main shock (Pulinets
et al., 1998b). Further, while forecasting the
time of the earthquake, forecasting of the magnitude
and seismic center may also be possible. But still
there is need to describe the ideal (in our view)
system of ionospheric precursor monitoring which
can demonstrate that ionospheric precursors satisfy
all the requirements of short term prediction
i.e. able to determine the place, the time and
intensity of the approaching quake. The main problems
now are lack of regular global data and paucity
of funds .Low cost small satellites offer a solution
to these problems. The low cost of the spacecraft
offers a financially low –risk approach
to the next step of this research (Jason et al.,
2003). At present several countries viz. Russia,
France, USA and Ukraine have already launched
dedicated satellites or at the threshold of launching
the satellite. After new results obtained onboard
Intercosmos –19(February 27th, 1979), Intercosmos-Bulgaria
1300(August 7th, 1981), Cosmos 1809(December 18th,
1986) and Aureol-3 (September 21st, 1981), it
was confirmed that the satellite observations
have the major advantage of covering almost all
the areas of seismic activities throughout the
world in short duration, and such observations
are useful only in case we could demonstrate their
seismotectonic origins and define all their characteristics/properties,
and their variability according to the conditions
of the rupture and their environment. Considering
these above facts, the scientists had decided
to create dedicated satellite missions specially
low cost small satellites. Russians took the initiative
in eighties and proposed two projects: Preduprezhdenie
(Warning) and DEMETER (Detection of Electromagnetic
Emissions Transmitted from Earthquake Regions).
But due to financial constraints, later in nineties
the projects were handed over to the partners:
the Warning mission to Ukraine and DEMETER to
France.
DEMETER Micro-satellite
DEMETER Satellite is the first of its kind
developed by the CENTRE NATIONAL D’ETUDES
SPATIALES (CNES), France and launched on 29
June, 2004 from Baikonour, Kazakhstan .The scientific
objectives of DEMETER are related to the investigation
of the ionospheric perturbations due to the
seismic activity, and also to the global study
of the Earth electromagnetic environment. The
main objectives of the DEMETER experiments are
to study the disturbances of the ionosphere
caused due to the seismo-electromagnetic effects
, and due to anthropogenic activities as shown
in Figure(2).
There are two modes of operation: -
(a) A survey mode to record low bit rate data
all around earth; and
(b) A burst mode to record high bit rate data
above seismic regions.
Sensors are associated to an electronic block
in order to digitize the signals and to perform
onboard data processing.
· ICE (Instrument Champ
Electrique), Measurement of quasi-continuous
electric fields and the electric components
of waves, three electric sensors from DC up
to 3.5 MHz;
· IMSC (Measuring the
magnetic components of waves), three magnetic
sensors for measuring magnetic field from a
few Hz up to 18 kHz;
· IAP (Instrument Analyseur
Plasma), measurement of plasma parameters, an
ion analyser;
· IDP (Measurement of
energetic particle spectra), an energetic particle
detector; and
· ISL (Measurement of
the characteristics of thermal plasma), a Langmuir
probe.
Proposed Ionospheric
parameters for measurement
Based on
retrospective analysis of existing satellite measurements
of seismo-ionospheric variations and existing
models, the following set of measurements has
been proposed -
· Measurements of the
six components of the electromagnetic wave field;
· Determination of the
plasma parameters at an altitude of 710kms;
· Measurement of ion composition
;
· Electron and ion temperature
measurements ; and
· Determination of energetic
particle precipitation.
(The technical details related to DEMETER satellite
can be obtained from the website: http:// www.demeter.cnrs-orleans.fr/
).
Result
Figure
(3) shows the plasma parameter variations and
VLF electric field burst recorded by the DEMETER
satellite on 7th January, 2005 seven days before
the earthquake (Mb=6.1) occurred on 14th January,2005
at 08:33:30UTC in the New Britain Region P.N.G(Lat.
-4.33N Long. 152.73E) .The closest approach to
the epicenter of the earthquake (dark red triangle)
is encircled . The data is presented as a function
of the Universal time (UT), the Local time (LT),
geographic latitude and longitude and the L values.
The bottom panel shows the earthquake monitored
by the satellite along the orbit. The Y-axis represents
the distance between the epicentre and the satellite
from 750 km to 2000 km. The green squares are
for post seismic events, red triangles for pre-seismic
events and filled with blue circles for earthquakes
occurring during the half orbit. The empty symbol
denotes the conjugate points with respect to the
epicentre of earthquake. The size of the symbol
indicates the magnitude of the seismic events.
The colour scale on the right represents the time
interval between the earthquakes and the DEMETER
orbit with a colour gradation from >30 days
up to [0 – 6h].
Limitations
DEMETER
has almost all the onboard experiments necessary
to register the plasma seismic precursors up to
an altitude of 710 km. But the only thing lacking
in the DEMETER satellite is the measurement of
electron concentration in the F-layer peak due
to low frequency of the installed receiver (3.5
MHz), use to measure the critical frequencies
.It could be done with the HF radiospectrometer
scaling as suggested by Pulinets et al., 2002c.
Conclusion
Among
the dedicated satellite missions the DEMETER micro-satellite
looks to be first of its kind in terms of earthquake
prediction from space. It has almost all the components/properties
necessary to register seismo- ionospheric effects,
except the measurement of F-layer critical frequency
(foF2) – the most sensitive parameter. Pulinets
in his book ‘ Ionospheric Precursors of
Earthquakes’ suggested that it is possible
to detect the critical frequency with the HF radiospectrometer
scaling the HF noises from broadcast transmitter
penetrating into topside ionosphere at frequencies
higher than the critical frequency. The authors
wish to suggest that if the frequency of the onboard
receiver increases to measure the critical frequency
of the F-layer peak the device would probably
become a promising tool in this invaluable research
and soon we could have a dedicated network of
small satellites for the earthquake prediction
studies.
Acknowledgement
The authors
are very much thankful to Laboratoire de Physique
and Chimie de l’Environnement (LPCE) for
providing processed data and Indo-French Center
for Promotion of Advance Research (IFCPAR) for
funding the project. The authors wish to extend
their gratitude to Prof. M. Parrot of LPCE, France
for his valuable guidance during this project.
References
Gokhberg,
B. M., Morgounov, A. V., Pokhotelov, A. O., ‘Earthquake
Prediction Seismo- Electromagnetic Phenomena’.,
1995, Gordon and Breach Publishers.
Gwal, A.K. , Shrivastava, A., and Malhotra, K.,
“Observation of Seismogenic ULF Electric
field FluctuationsDetected as a Burst in the Ionosphere
during the Tsunamis over the Andaman and Nicobar
Islands”, Curr. Sci. vol.91, pp. 229-234,
2006.
Jason, S. , Pulinets, S., Curiel, A., and Sweeting,
M. Sir., “Earthquake forecast Science Research
with a Small Satellite” usuh Annual /Small
Satellites Conference August 2002,SSCO2-IX-5.
Jason, S. , Pulinets, S., Curiel, A., and Liddle,
D., “Earthquake science research with a
microsatellite” Phil. Trans. R.Soc.Lond.
A(2003) 361,1-5.
Parrot, M., 2002, The micro-satellite Demeter:
Data registration and data processing, in Seismo
Electromagnetics lithosphere – Atmosphere
– Ionosphere Coupling, ed. by Hayakawa,
M. and Molchanov , O. A., Y., Terra Sci, pub.
Co. Tokya, pp. 391-395.
Pokhotelov, O.A. et al., Response of the ionosphere
to natural and man made acoustic sources, Ann.
Geophys.,13,1197-1210,1995. Pulinets, S.A. 1998b
Strong earthquake possibility with the help of
topside sounding from satellites. Adv. Space Res.
21, 455-458.
Pulinets, S.A., K. A. Boyarchuk, A. M. Lomonosov,
V. V. Khegai, and J. Y. Liu, Ionospheric Precursors
to Earthquakes: A Preliminary Analysis of the
foF2 Critical Frequencies at Chung- Li Ground-Based
Station for Vertical Sounding of the Ionosphere
(Taiwan Island), Geomagnetism and Aeronomy, 2002,
42, No. 3, pp.508-513.
Pulinets, S., Boyarchuk , K., 2003, ‘Ionospheric
Precursors of Earthquakes’, pub., Springer
Berlin Heidelberg, New York.
Prof.
A. K. Gwal
Dean, Faculty of Science and Head, Department
of Physics, Barkatullah University, Bhopal,
India. splakg@sancharnet.in
Abhishek
Shrivastava
Junior Research Fellow under DST Project
at Space Science
Laboratory, Barkatullah University. hopeeverexi sts@rediffmail.com
Kalpana
Malhotra
Senior Research Fellow under Indo French
Center for the romotion of Advanced Research
(IFCPAR) Project at Space Science Laboratory,
Barkatullah University. kmalhotra111@rediffmail.com